Dogtra ARC-X vs 1900X: The Best E-Collar for Dogs (2025 Review)

Dogtra ARC-X vs 1900X: Which E-Collar Is Right for Your Dog in 2025?

If you’re searching for a reliable, pro-grade e-collar, Dogtra is a top choice trusted by professional trainers, hunters, and everyday pet owners. Known for their durability, precision, and intuitive design, Dogtra collars are built for real-life training—whether you’re working with a stubborn shepherd, an energetic retriever, or a reactive rescue pup.

Two standout models, the Dogtra ARC-X and Dogtra 1900X Remote Training E-Collar, are packed with features to make training easier and more effective. But how do you choose between them?

Let’s break down what each offer so you can find the best e-collar for your dog’s size, temperament, and lifestyle.

What Is an E-Collar?

Also known as a remote training collar, an e-collar allows you to communicate with your dog using adjustable stimulation, vibration, or tone. Unlike outdated shock collars, today’s e-collars are safe, humane, and highly customizable, making them ideal for:

• Off-leash training
• Recall and heel commands
• Behavior correction
• Fieldwork or hunting
• Building better communication and trust

Why Dog Owners Choose Dogtra

• IPX9K Waterproof Rating – Built tough for all weather and terrain
• Ergonomic Fit – Lightweight, contoured receiver collars
• Hands-Free Options – For active training and multitasking
• Trusted by Professionals – Used by K9 handlers, sport dog trainers, and pet owners alike

Dogtra ARC-X Remote Training E-Collar: Sleek & Sensitive

Who It’s For:

• Small to medium dogs
• Urban and home-based training
• Pet owners who want subtle, everyday control

Key Benefits:

• Low-profile design: 30% smaller than the 1900X with Dogtra’s proprietary ergo curve for natural comfort. At just 2.75 oz, your dog will barely notice it.
• Ultra-precise stimulation: Perfect for sensitive dogs requiring gentle but effective training.
• Multi-dog training: Expandable to train up to 3 dogs with one remote.
• Quiet environments: Non-stimulating pager (XPP vibration) mode helps redirect behavior gently without disruption.
• Brightest LED: Enhances visibility during low-light conditions.
• Fully waterproof: IPX9K rated for durability in all weather and environments.

Ideal For:

✔ Basic obedience
✔ Leash training
✔ Socialization and recall in parks or public areas

Recommended for first-time e-collar users or those training small to mid-sized pets.

Product Details:

• Range: 3/4 mile
• Output Level: Medium
• Receiver Weight: 2.75 oz
• Waterproof: IPX9K rated
• Expandable: Yes, up to 3 dogs
• Price: $254.99

Check out the all-new Dogtra ARC-X here.

Dogtra 1900X Remote Training Collar: Powerful & Rugged

Who It's For:

• Large, stubborn, or working breeds
• Active owners and professionals
• Anyone who wants advanced control features

Key Benefits:

• High-output correction: Effective for headstrong dogs or serious behavior issues.
• One-handed control: Central command button for quick responses.
• Durable, waterproof design: Built to handle the elements and extended use.
• LED collar light: Enhances visibility during nighttime walks or low-light conditions.
• Expandable system: Train up to 3 dogs simultaneously with additional collars.

Ideal For:

 ✔ Outdoor training
 ✔ Hunting and fieldwork
 ✔ Working dog routines

Recommended for experienced trainers and active owners with large breeds.

Product Details:

• Best for: Large breeds (35 lbs and up) or stubborn dogs
• Output Level: High
• Range: ¾ mile
• Weight: 5.6 oz (receiver)
• Waterproof: Yes (IPX9K rated)
• Price: $254.99

Get your Dogtra 1900X here. Also comes in Black, Camouflage, and Handsfree.

Side-by-Side Comparison: ARC-X vs. 1900X

Which Dogtra E-Collar Is Right for You?

Choose ARC-X if you:

• Have a small or medium size dog
• Prefer a slim, low-profile design
• Need a remote training collar for city walks, dog parks, or home training
• Want a simple, effective solution without high power

Choose 1900X if you:

• Own a large or stubborn dog that requires firmer correction
• Spend time hiking, hunting, or running with your dog
• Want advanced control features and remote flexibility
• Need more powerful stimulation and additional training options

If you’d like a closer look at its features and benefits, here’s a helpful article on the Dogtra 1900X dog training collar.

Final Thoughts: ARC-X vs. 1900X

Both the Dogtra ARC-X and 1900X are top-tier e-collars with features built for serious training. The ARC-X is sleek, compact, and perfect for sensitive dogs and everyday training. The 1900X delivers strength, range, and advanced features for larger, more driven dogs and active lifestyles.

Train smarter. Communicate better. Strengthen your bonds.

Choose the Dogtra collar that aligns with your training goals—and enjoy more freedom, safety, and confidence with your dog by your side.