The Best Shock Collars for Stubborn Dogs
All dogs go to heaven, as the saying goes. That doesn't mean they're all angels all the time on earth, though. Even the most adorable-looking canine can sometimes have a headstrong and stubborn streak. Problematic behaviors can also develop due to a lack of training or socialization. When a dog's behavior becomes challenging, it can frustrate the pet owner. Many even get to the point of giving up.
But don’t lose hope just yet. Behavioral issues can be curbed. And one of the best ways to do it is with the help of a remote training collar.
What is a Shock Collar for Dogs?
Shock collars are a type of collar initially used to train hunting dogs in the 1960s. Old, archaic shock collars are clunky and have limited stimulation controls and levels. Shock collars have come a long way since then. Modern shock collars, also known as e-collars or remote dog training collars, are much more humane and offer various training options other than just shock or electric stimulation.
Remote trainers have two metal prongs that rest against the dog's skin on the neck area. These prongs, called contact points, deliver static stimulation when a button is pressed on the transmitter remote. Other trainers prefer to use something other than static, however. Fortunately, e-collars provide other stimulation options like vibration, tone, and spray.
Can I Use a Shock Collar for Stubborn Dogs?
Dog training takes time and commitment. But with consistent effort and positive reinforcement, you can have a well-behaved pet. A word of caution, however. While e-collars are never meant to be used to hurt your pets, it's easy to do so if you do not know what you are doing. So before using an e collar for dog training, learn everything you can about proper usage. There are plenty of training videos available online. If unsure, talk to your veterinarian or get professional dog training help.
How to Choose a Shock Collar for Stubborn Dogs
There are many available shock collars in the market today from reputable brands like PetSafe, SportDog, Dogtra, E-Collar Technologies, and more. There are also as many, if not more, made by brands you have yet to hear of. When choosing what is best to use for your stubborn pet, consider the following.
- Training Modes – you want a remote e-collar that gives you stimulation options other than static, as not all dogs will react well to it.
- Range – while a 100-yard range is more than enough for basic obedience training at home (or in your yard), if you have plans of taking your dog farther afield (or if you have a pet prone to bolting), having an e collar with longer range is handier.
- Size and Fit – collar straps are always adjustable, so it shouldn't be a problem regardless of your dog's neck size. However, the receiver box can vary in weight. If you have a tiny dog, you'd want to get an e-collar with a lighter receiver to avoid straining your dog.
- Contact Points – most e-collar sets already include a couple pairs of contact points in varying lengths. Make sure you use one that reaches your dog's skin without poking. A dog with a thick, dense coat may need longer prongs, while a dog with shorter hair will be better with shorter ones.
If you’re ready to start training your pet, PetsTEK has put together a list of the best dog training collars for stubborn dogs based on experience, reviews, and trainer recommendations.
PetsTEK’s Picks for the Best Shock Collars for Stubborn Dogs
Best Over-All: Mini Educator ET-300 Remote Training Collar by E-Collar Technologies
The Mini Educator ET-300, with its distinctive yellow, stopwatch-style remote, is a fixture in many "best shock collar" lists. And it's with good reason. This Educator shock collar may be small, but it is powerful. With 100 levels of static stimulation, vibration, and tone options, it's easy to find the best level for any dog of any temperament. It also has 60 levels of additional boost for those highly distracting situations where extra stim is needed. The ET-300 has a range of ½-mile, making it suitable for yard and field training. Expandable to a 2-dog system. Comes in yellow, black, and Educator Zen 300 design variants.
Best for Multiple Training Use: Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar
Dogtra has been making e-collars for over three decades, and it shows. Dogtra shock collars are durable and dependable. The 1900S is a fully waterproof remote trainer with a range of ¾-mile. It has 127 levels of static stimulation and a high-performance pager vibration. Ideal for dogs 35 pounds or more, the 1900S also comes in a black edition with a longer range of 1 mile. This shock collar is excellent for training hunting, K-9, and service dogs with normal and stubborn temperaments. It's also a competent basic obedience trainer.
Best for Aggressive Dogs: Boss Educator ET-800 Remote Training Collar by E-Collar Technologies
Like the Mini Educator, the Boss Educator also features a round stopwatch remote transmitter, this time in black (although different colored skins are available for purchase). The Boss has a range of 1 mile and provides effective correction for dogs 20 pounds or larger.
Best for Hunting Dogs: SportDog 425X Field Trainer Remote Training Collar
SportDog collars were originally designed for hunting dog training. The SD-425X FieldTrainer is no exception. However, you will find that SportDog e-collars are also some of the most flexible shock collars in terms of intended use. While it is an effective hunting dog trainer, the 425X is also quite handy for basic obedience training. The smallest and lightest among all SportDog shock collars, the 425X has a 500-yard range and 21 levels of static stimulation, vibration, and tone. Ideal for dogs 8 pounds and larger, this remote training collar is expandable for up to 3 dogs and also comes with a 425XS version for even more stubborn pets.
Dog Training, E-Collar Info & Guides, Obedience Training, Pet Training, Remote Training Collar, Training Tips