Dogtra 1900X vs. 1900S: A Side-by-Side Comparison

Training dogs off-leash can be challenging, especially when they’re prone to getting distracted or excited. Dogtra’s 1900X and 1900S e-collars offer solutions that make off-leash training manageable, effective, and safe. But with Dogtra’s newer model – the 1900X – owners now have access to enhanced features that promise improved functionality.

This article will help you decide which model best suits your needs by breaking down the key features of the Dogtra 1900X and 1900S. Read on.

But First, What is an E-Collar?

E-collars enable precise off-leash dog training using static, vibration, or tone signals. These remote training tools help reinforce commands and modify behaviors even at a distance.

Why Choose Dogtra?

Dogtra is a trusted leader in the dog training collar industry, renowned for its commitment to quality, safety, and innovation. Their extensive product range includes remote training collars, no bark collars, an e-fence system, and GPS tracking collars. With this diverse lineup, Dogtra offers solutions for every training need – from basic obedience to bark control and precise tracking.

1900X vs. 1900S: Key Upgrades in the New Dogtra X-Series

The 2024 release of Dogtra’s X-Series redefines remote training collars, offering a smoother and more powerful training experience. The X-Series is built to be your ultimate training partner, seamlessly blending advanced technology with ease of use. Whether you're dealing with basic commands or more challenging behaviors, the X-Series ensures your dog receives the precise training and attention they need.

If you’re upgrading from the 1900S or making a first-time purchase, the 1900X introduces several improvements that enhance training effectiveness. Here’s what you need to know:

Feature Highlight #1: Stimulation Control

The 1900X features a Safety Stimulation Level Lock that prevents accidental changes to the stimulation level, enhancing safety during training. It also has a streamlined range of 100 stimulation levels, enabling quick and precise adjustments while maintaining control.

For comparison, the stimulation level of 127 on the 1900S is equivalent to level 100 on the 1900X, as shown in the chart below: 

While the 1900S offers the same range of control, it lacks the level lock feature. This absence may be significant for owners seeking an extra layer of security during training sessions.

Feature Highlight #2: Stimulation Output and Modes

Both the 1900X and 1900S are high-output collars, designed for larger or more stubborn dogs weighing 35 pounds or more. However, the 1900X boasts an Extreme Performance Pager (XPP) that delivers a more intense vibration compared to the High Performance Pager (HPP) found in the 1900S. This is particularly beneficial for dogs that respond better to stronger non-static cues.

Additionally, the 1900X includes:

• Audible Tone mode: Provides sound-based corrections, effective for sound-sensitive dogs (not available in the 1900S).
• Boost button: Allows users to instantly raise the stimulation level, perfect for redirecting a dog’s focus in urgent situations (not available in the 1900S).

Feature Highlight #3: Range

Both collars offer a ¾-mile range, giving you control over your dog even at greater distances. This range is particularly beneficial for off-leash activities, like hiking or field training.

Feature Highlight #4: Single vs. Multi-Dog Capability

The 1900X supports an expandable 3-dog system with additional collars, making it ideal for multi-dog households or trainers. For those interested in a 2-dog version, the 1900X-2 Dog remote trainer is also available. In contrast, the 1900S is designed as a 1-dog system and was previously available in a 2-dog model (1902S), which has been discontinued. This limitation makes the 1900S less suitable for households with multiple dogs.

Feature Highlight #5: Durability and Build Quality

Both Dogtra units are IPX9K certified, ensuring full waterproof protection against extreme conditions. However, the 1900X remote includes an “X-Shield” case cover for extreme durability, making it suitable for intense, high-energy training in all conditions.

Feature Highlight #6: Battery and Charging

Both models feature a fast-charging, 2-hour lithium-polymer battery. However, the 1900X includes a USB-C charger for easier and faster charging on the go.

Additional Features Unique to the 1900X

While both the Dogtra 1900X and 1900S share a strong foundation, the 1900X offers several standout features that set it apart:

1. LED Locate Light

One of the key additions in the 1900X is the 1000 Lux LED Locate Light on the receiver. This feature greatly enhances safety by making your dog visible during nighttime walks or dusk training – a feature absent in the 1900S.

2. Programmable Command Button

The 1900X adds a Programmable Command Button, allowing users to customize it for quick access to their preferred training modes or settings. This makes training more convenient and efficient.

3. Removable Contact Points

The 1900X also comes with removable contact points, allowing for non-stimulation training when needed. This gives owners the flexibility to use the collar without static correction.

These exclusive features make the Dogtra 1900X the superior choice for those seeking greater customization in their training.

Pros and Cons Summary: 1900X vs. 1900S

Dogtra 1900X Remote Training Collar

Pros:

• Supports up to three dogs
• Command button
• X-Shield for enhanced durability
• Audible tone
• Extreme Performance Pager (XPP) vibration
• Safety stimulation level lock
• LED locate light
• USB-C charging

Con:

• Slightly higher price, but justified by extra features and durability

Dogtra 1900S  Remote Training Collar

Pros:

• More affordable option
• Strong performance with High Performance Pager (HPP)
• Ideal for single-dog households or basic training needs

Cons:

• Lacks LED locate light
• No audible tone feature
• No safety level lock
• Not ideal for multi-dog households

Which Model is Right for You?

• Choose the 1900S if: You’re looking for reliable, straightforward functionality, perfect for single households needing basic training support.

• Choose the 1900X if: You’re looking for the best in dog training technology. With expanded features like multi-dog support, enhanced durability, XPP vibration, and added safety and visibility options, the 1900X is perfect for professional trainers, owners with multiple dogs, or those requiring advanced tools for intensive training sessions.

Final Thoughts

The Dogtra 1900X builds on the solid foundation of the 1900S by incorporating exclusive features that enhance durability, ease of use, and multi-dog handling.

You might also enjoy...