In the world of dog training, e-collars have emerged as a powerful tool for dog owners and trainers. Two models consistently top the charts: the Mini Educator ET-300 and the Garmin PRO 550. Their effectiveness and range of features are undeniable, but with so much to consider, choosing between them can feel overwhelming.

This blog post is here to help you navigate that very decision. We'll be taking a deep dive into the features, pros, and cons of both the ET-300 and the PRO 550 e collars. By the end, you'll have the knowledge and confidence to pick the e-collar that perfectly complements your training style and your dog's needs.

What Is an E Collar for Dogs?

An e collar is a dog training tool that helps in teaching obedience and correcting unwanted behavior. It can deliver a variety of stimuli, such as a mild electric shock, vibration, or sound.

An e-collar device typically consists of a handheld remote and a collar receiver that the dog wears around its neck. When the trainer presses a button on the remote, it sends a signal to the dog collar. The collar then sends a short vibration or mild static to get the dog's attention. This helps the trainer communicate with the dog during training.

Head-to-Head Comparison: ET-300 vs PRO 550

Comparison #1: Range

Range refers to the maximum distance at which the handheld transmitter can communicate with the receiver on your dog's collar. Remember, this is under ideal conditions with no obstructions.

While both remote training collars offer a decent range, the Garmin PRO 550 boasts a slight advantage with its 1-mile reach. This can be beneficial for training in open fields or with dogs that tend to wander further during sessions. However, the Mini Educator ET-300's half-mile range is still suitable for most backyards, parks, or training walks. Remember, terrain and obstacles can affect the signal strength for both models.

Comparison #2: Stimulation Levels

Stimulation levels refer to the intensity of the electrical pulse delivered by the dog training e-collar. Having more levels allows you to increase the intensity in very small increments. This is important because you always want to use the lowest effective level during training.

The Mini Educator ET-300 offers a wide range of stimulation levels (0-100), giving you high customization options. This Educator collar also offers a "Boost" function with 1-60 levels. It allows you to deliver a stronger stimulation in situations where your dog might need a more immediate or urgent correction.

On the other hand, the Garmin PRO 550 has fewer main stimulation levels compared to the ET-300. However, each of these 21 levels has sub-levels within them (low, medium, and high). This might actually provide more nuanced adjustments without being too strong, potentially leading to faster calibration.

Comparison #3: Training Modes

Both the ET-300 and PRO 550 provide a versatile toolbox for dog training. They share essential modes like continuous stimulation, momentary stimulation, vibration, and tone.

However, one key advantage of the Mini Educator dog collar is its unique "Pavlovian Tone" feature. When activated, your dog hears a brief tone before receiving any stimulation, unless you release the button. Over time, your dog will associate the tone with the stimulation, responding to the tone alone without requiring stimulation.

Comparison #4: Number of Dogs Controlled

Are you considering training multiple dogs? Both the Mini Educator and Garmin PRO 550 offer the capability to expand your training beyond a single canine companion. However, they differ in the number of dogs you can control in one handheld transmitter.

The ET-30 can handle 2 dogs at once but requires purchasing an extra collar. Meanwhile, the PRO 550 e-collar boasts the ability to control up to 3 dogs simultaneously. However, similar to the ET-300, you'll need to buy extra dog collars for each additional dog you want to train. Hence, if you only need to train 2 dogs, the Mini Educator ET-300 should be sufficient.

Comparison #5: Display

When choosing an e-collar for training multiple dogs, display options can be a deciding factor. The Mini Educator e collar features a LED display that shows the stimulation level, training mode, and which dog is being controlled. In contrast, the Garmin PRO 550 takes a minimalist design and does not include a screen. Hence, if you prefer an e collar with clear visual information, the ET-300 remote training collar might be a better choice.

Comparison #6: Size and Weight

When selecting an e-collar for dog training, size and weight shouldn't be overlooked. A comfortable fit can significantly impact your training experience, especially for smaller breeds.

The ET-300 dog training collar shines with its compact and lightweight design. Its receiver collar weighs a mere 2.4 ounces, making it a perfect choice for smaller dogs. The Garmin PRO 550, on the other hand, is slightly larger and heavier than the ET-300. This size difference might not be a major concern for larger breeds. However, a larger collar could feel bulky and cumbersome on a smaller dog. Ultimately, either option could work depending on your specific needs and dog’s size.

Comparison #7: Bark Control

While both dog shock collars excel in dog off-leash training, the PRO 550 goes a step further by integrating a BarkLimiter function. This built-in bark control system allows you to address unwanted barking directly through the e-collar. This innovative feature takes the guesswork out of correction levels, since it automatically adjusts the intensity based on your dog's bark.

Garmin e-collars offer a distinct advantage by combining a remote dog training collar and bark collar in one device. This eliminates the need for a separate bark control device, resulting in a more streamlined and cost-effective solution. The ET-300 lacks this feature, so addressing excessive barking would require a separate device, the BP-504 no bark collar.

Similar Features

While we've focused on the differences, the ET-300 and Pro 550 also share some key features. Both e-collars are rechargeable and their handheld transmitters float on water too. Additionally, both models feature LED lights on the dog collar, providing improved visibility in low-light conditions.

Pros and Cons

Feeling overloaded by the details mentioned above? Don’t worry. Here's a breakdown of the key differences between the ET-300 Mini Educator and Garmin PRO 550 to help you decide:

Mini Educator ET-300 Remote Dog Training Collar

Price: $199.99

Feature Summary

• ½-Mile Range
• 1-100 User-Selectable Levels of Wide Pulse Stimulation
• 1-60 Levels Additional Boost
• Pavlovian Tone and Non-Stimulating Vibration
• Lock and Set Technology
• Ergonomic “Stopwatch” Transmitter
• Small Receiver
• Waterproof
• LED Light Feature for Night Visibility
• Rechargeable Lithium-Polymer Battery
• Expandable to 2-Dog System
• For Dogs 8 Pounds and Larger

Garmin PRO 550 Remote Training Collar

Price: $399.99

Feature Summary

• 1-Mile Range
• 21 Stimulation Levels
• Momentary/Continuous Stim (Low, Medium, and High)
• Vibration and Tone Settings
• Built-In BarkLimiter Feature
• Beacon Lights
• Expandable to 3 Dogs
• Allows Adding the Garmin Upland Beeper (sold separately)
• Waterproof Handheld
• Rechargeable

Choosing the Right E-Collar

Both the Mini Educator ET-300 and Garmin Pro 550 are capable e-collars, but they have distinct strengths.

If you're on a budget and have a small dog, the Mini Educator ET-300 is a great choice. This lightweight option is cost-effective and features a convenient LED display to show the settings and the currently controlled dog.

For those seeking an extended range and finer control, the Garmin Pro 550 takes the lead. Plus, it has a built-in BarkLimiter to curb excessive barking. It’s also perfect for training up to 3 dogs with a purchase of extra collars.

Ultimately, the best choice depends on your training goals and budget. Consider the features most important to you and your furry friend.

Final Word

You might also enjoy...